Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Trigger Warning.

I recently found myself in a rare situation:  I was walking past Tanglewood Books, a used bookstore which is actually located in the same block as our apartment*, and I realized that I was not holding hands with my lovely wife Karli**, laden with groceries, hurrying to get home, or otherwise prevented from browsing the store's stock.

As such, I decided to seize the moment, made my way inside, nodded to the proprietor, and spent some time in the science fiction and fantasy section. I picked out two trade paperbacks: a copy of The Three Body Problem by Liu Cixin, which I had read but not really enjoyed when it first came out, but felt that it deserved a second chance in the wake of its Hugo win in 2014; and The View From The Cheap Seats, a collection of non-fiction by Neil Gaiman.

It was only after I returned home with my purchases that I had a sudden moment of doubt regarding my Neil Gaiman purchase, as held up against the various accusations of sexual misconduct and rape on his part. In the interest of fairness, I acknowledge that none of the allegations against Neil Gaiman have been proven in court, but public opinion has definitively made its decision known through the quiet cancellation of a wide range of projects involving Mr. Gaiman.  

Gaiman is hardly the first writer with a less than admirable private life. Horror icon H. P. Lovecraft's writing blatantly reflected his racism***; John W. Campbell, science fiction author and one of the most influential editors of SF's Golden Age, was a right-wing fanatic who felt that slavery had improved the quality of life for the Africans who were forcibly transported to the United States; L. Ron Hubbard's pseudo-scientific beliefs led him to the creation of Scientology; and J. K. Rowlings well-known anti-trans and gender-critical sentiments have polarized the Harry Potter fan base.

However, none of that removes the work of those authors from the history of the genre. Lovecraft's racism doesn't change the degree to which his writing has shaped modern horror, nor do John W. Campbell's extremist views diminish his influence on the development of science fiction.  However, what does change is the manner in which their work is viewed.  Scholarship requires that Neil Gaiman's work be recognized, with the understanding that it must also be viewed through the filter of his transgressions. As such, I will be keeping my purchase - at least in the short term, who knows what the future holds in terms of further revelations.

- Sid

* To date in my retirement, I haven't felt it necessary to find some kind of little part time job to help with finances, but if Tanglewood were to put a sign in their windows advertising for part time help, I would be terribly tempted. Working in a used bookstore would be a bit of a dream job - and the commute would be so short that I would almost not need a jacket in winter.

** In saying this, I do my wife a mild injustice - I'm sure that she would be perfecting willing to stop for a minute so that I could do some browsing, but it feels like an imposition.  

*** In a touch of mild irony, The View From The Cheap Seats contains Gaiman's introduction to a collection of Lovecraft's short stories, which briefly mentions that Lovecraft was "a believer in unpleasant doctrines of racial superiority" and an Anglophile, as if these are somehow equivalent attributes.

No comments:

Post a Comment